Cooperating Witnesses in Criminal Cases Explained

A cooperating witness is someone who assists a law enforcement agency or prosecutors in building a case against someone else. This typically happens in exchange for reduced charges or sentences, or another form of leniency. They often testify against co-defendants in their cases or cooperate to help close other criminal cases.

Your Philadelphia criminal defense lawyer can discuss whether this type of plea bargain or agreement is possible in your case. Acting as a cooperating witness could help you get a better outcome, including avoiding extended time behind bars or other serious consequences.

How does being a Cooperating Witness Work?

When individuals have information or access to criminal enterprises that law enforcement or prosecutors value, it may be possible to exchange testimony, details, or other evidence for a dropped charge, reduced charges, or a lenient sentence.

The key aspects of a cooperating witness include:

Unique knowledge or access about a crime or into a criminal enterprise
Willingness to provide testimony against others as necessary
An agreement to receive leniency in exchange for cooperation
This arrangement is usually formalized through a plea agreement with prosecutors

This is not an agreement you want to try to negotiate or discuss with law enforcement or prosecutors without first talking to your defense attorney about your options. Whether this is your best option will depend on the details of your case.

For a free legal consultation, call 215.515.3360

What Statutes Address Witnesses Who Cooperate with Authorities?

Pennsylvania lawmakers have not directly defined cooperating witnesses or how these agreements work. However, there are several relevant laws related to plea agreements and witness testimony in exchange for leniency. This includes:

234 Pa. Code Rule 590: This rule governs plea agreements in Pennsylvania criminal courts. It outlines the process and determines when a defendant can make an agreement with prosecutors, which could include cooperating in exchange for lesser charges or a lenient sentence.
18 Pa. Code § 4902: This statute requires a cooperating witness to testify truthfully and outlines the consequences for false statements during testimony.

These laws provide structure for cooperating witness agreements. They ensure the witnesses are legally bound to provide honest testimony. This prevents those who do not have useful information to help law enforcement from pushing for this type of agreement.

They also ensure that prosecutors and courts can take a defendant’s cooperation with local police or another law enforcement agency into account when choosing charges or during sentencing. This is necessary to ensure they can uphold their end of the deal.

Acting as a Cooperating Witness as Part of Your Defense Strategy

In some cases, you could include being a cooperating witness as a key component in your defense strategy. While it might not fully exonerate you, it could reduce your sentence or result in probation instead of jail time. It is important to note that you will only receive leniency in your case if it helps the police or prosecutors.

If you believe you might be in a good position to be a cooperating witness, you should talk to your lawyer. It is important to discuss your options with an attorney because police officers can lie to you about some topics and under certain circumstances. You do not want to be misled or misunderstand how this process will work. It is also important to ensure it offers you the best possible outcome in your case before committing.

You must also consider the effect this could have on your own life. Cooperating witnesses are known as “snitches” by others serving time in the criminal justice system. This could make you a target or require protective custody if you receive a jail or prison sentence. Depending on the circumstances, you may need to discuss steps to protect yourself from retaliation in your daily life.

What is the Role of a Criminal Defense Attorney in Representing a Cooperating Witness?

When you talk to your attorney about cooperating as a witness, they can help you weigh the advantages and disadvantages of cooperation with the police and prosecutors. This is not the best option for all defendants in criminal cases. Some can fight for better outcomes without taking the risks that come with cooperating with authorities.

For example, your attorney may believe you have a strong case for getting evidence barred from court or winning an acquittal based on the available evidence. In either of these cases, the disadvantages of being a cooperating witness only to still need to serve jail time and pay fines does not make sense when it might be possible to clear your name entirely.

Depending on the accusations against you, there may be other options that could prevent a conviction and keep it off your record. Call an attorney as soon as possible following your arrest. They can help you explore possible actions such as:

Getting evidence thrown out because of police errors
Presenting evidence to clear your name before they file charges
Qualifying for a diversionary program that drops the charges after completion
Building a strong case to win an acquittal at trial

Having a lawyer on your side is the best way to develop a strong defense strategy to receive a positive outcome. For some, this could be through cooperating with a criminal investigation, testifying against a co-defendant, or testifying in another case.

Discuss Your Legal Options with Our Criminal Defense Attorneys Today

At the Law Offices of M.J. Snyder, LLC, we offer a free consultation. You can discuss your case and defense options with our legal team during this confidential consultation. We will assess your next steps and can represent you in questioning or any court appearances. We will offer advice and guidance for all your legal options, including acting as a cooperating witness.